What Can You Do If Your Tenant Is a Hoarder?

Contents of This Article

Tenant screening can help landlords determine whether applicants meet established rental criteria, but some property condition concerns may not become apparent until after a tenancy begins. Hoarding, for instance, may develop or become noticeable over time and can create significant health, safety, and maintenance concerns in a rental property. Today, we’ll review what hoarding is, how it can impact rentals, what signs landlords may notice, and how to address potential issues while complying with Fair Housing requirements.

Main Takeaways

  • Hoarding disorder is a mental health condition that can create health, safety, and maintenance concerns in rental properties.
  • Landlords should approach hoarding situations with compassion while following the Fair Housing Act and applicable landlord-tenant laws.
  • Thorough documentation, regular inspections, and clear lease terms can help protect both the property and the tenant.

Tenant living in a cluttered rental home due to hoarding disorderWhat Is Hoarding?

Thanks to modern reality television, you may know what hoarding is and what it looks like. However, it’s not always like what you see on TV and can be different for each individual case. That said, it’s important for landlords and property managers in Richmond to understand hoarding, how it may impact rentals, and what they can do if they find out a tenant suffers from hoarding disorder. 

Hoarding is a mental health condition that causes people to acquire and store large amounts of items. According to the American Psychiatric Association, people with hoarding disorder have difficulty getting rid of possessions due to a perceived need to save them. That said, there’s a major difference between collecting and hoarding. 

Collectors intentionally acquire items related to a theme or interest and store them neatly in a way they can enjoy. While they may also have emotional attachments to their items, collectors can typically let go of items without severe distress.

On the other hand, people with hoarding disorder excessively accumulate items, regardless of their value or functionality. Because of their excessive and unorganized nature, these items often lead to disorganized and cluttered living spaces. 

Why Is Hoarding Bad for Rentals?

Hoarding can be problematic for rental properties for several reasons. While you may think it’s just an excessive amount of useless items, it can be a lot more than that. These piles of possessions can cause numerous issues and may even violate a lease agreement. Here are some of the main reasons hoarding can impact rental properties. 

  • Potential Pest Problems- Pile-ups of items like old mail, magazines, or books appeal to mice who use these items to make nests. However, it doesn’t stop there–these piles of items can also bring in bedbugs, fleas, and other unwanted pests.
  • Fire Hazards- With things piled up and electrical outlets blocked, a fire can quickly damage a rental unit. Additionally, if a fire happens in the rental unit, piles of debris can make it difficult for firefighters to rescue the occupants.
  • Plumbing Issues- With items piled up in and around the bathroom, chances are either something will clog the toilet or the plumbing may break. That Cluttered kitchen in a rental property showing potential health and safety concernssaid, a backed-up toilet or bathtub can lead to larger issues, like poor air quality and structural damage.
  • Poor Sanitation- In some cases, hoarding behaviors may involve excessive numbers of animals. As you can imagine, this can cause a plethora of issues, from pests and mold to air quality issues. Additionally, if the animals aren’t being properly cared for, they may start relieving themselves around the home, leading to odors, damage, and other issues. 
  • Neighbor Complaints- Hoarding can lead to unpleasant odors, pest infestations that impact other properties, and issues that may disturb neighbors–especially in an apartment complex.
  • Safety Hazards- Landlords generally have obligations under state and local law to maintain rental properties in a safe and habitable condition. If conditions in the unit violate applicable health or safety requirements, landlords may need to take appropriate action to address the violations.

Signs of Potential Hoarding in a Rental Property

Hoarding can be extremely complicated, and each person is different. However, some of the major warning signs are obvious disorganization and unwillingness to allow others into their unit. After all, some people with hoarding disorder may feel embarrassed or uncomfortable allowing others into their living space and might resist having other people in their unit. That said, landlords may generally conduct lawful inspections or enter for permitted purposes in accordance with the lease and applicable state and local notice requirements.

Some other signs that may indicate potential hoarding-related conditions in a rental include the following.

  • Clutter seen through windows or outside of a rental unit
  • Strong odors in or around the unit
  • Sightings of pests in or around the unit
  • Complaints from neighbors about clutter or smells
  • Excessive accumulation of unusual items
  • Unresolved maintenance issues

What Can Landlords Do About It?

If you notice that your tenant is a hoarder, you may feel like eviction is the only option. However, sometimes, it’s not an option. Knowing how the Fair Housing Act plays a part in your ability to handle these scenarios is crucial. Because hoarding disorder may qualify as a disability under the Fair Housing Act, landlords must be careful to avoid disability discrimination and comply with applicable reasonable accommodation requirements. So, here are a few things you can do to protect yourself and your properties. 

  1. Communicate With Compassion and Empathy
  2. Understand the Legal Framework
  3. Establish a Cleanliness Clause
  4. Keep Detailed Records of Everything
  5. Offer Mental Health Resources
  6. Consider Legal Action if Necessary
  7. Prevent Future Issues

Communicate With Compassion and Empathy

Tenants with hoarding disorder may be embarrassed and avoid discussing their condition. As such, landlords or property managers should approach conversations with kindness and focus on showing concern for their well-being and the property’s condition. 

Understand Legal Implications

Hoarding disorder may qualify as a disability under the Fair Housing Act, meaning landlords must avoid discriminating against tenants because of a disability and comply with applicable reasonable accommodation requirements. However, if their hoarding issue is causing major issues with your property, you may need to take legal action.

Before-and-after comparison showing the importance of cleanliness standards in a rental propertyEstablish a Cleanliness Clause

To avoid any major issues from the start, clearly outline your expectations for cleanliness and maintenance in the lease agreement. Any clauses you add regarding cleanliness must be reasonable and aligned with local health and safety standards. Additionally, tenants need to understand their responsibilities from the start of their tenancy. 

Keep Detailed Records of Everything

It’s crucial to keep records of all communications related to a tenant’s hoarding issue, including any notices you send, inspections, and agreements made. Additionally, take photos during any inspections to document the property’s condition. This can be crucial if legal action becomes necessary for any reason. 

Offer Mental Health Resources

Just like any mental health condition, it’s hard to understand it unless you struggle with it yourself. Hoarding disorder is just the same. So, if you know that your tenant is struggling, see what you can do to help them, whether it’s sharing resources for local mental health services or encouraging professional cleaning services to help clean up their space. 

Consider Legal Action if Necessary

If a tenant’s hoarding creates serious health, safety, property damage, or lease-compliance concerns, landlords should document the specific conditions and communicate what needs to be corrected. If the tenant requests a reasonable accommodation related to a disability, the landlord should evaluate the request in accordance with Fair Housing requirements before proceeding with enforcement when applicable. However, if serious health, safety, property damage, or lease violations remain unresolved after applicable accommodation obligations have been considered, landlords may want to consult an attorney before pursuing eviction or other legal action.

Prevent Future Issues

Landlords can help prevent property-related issues by using consistent tenant screening criteria and clearly outlining cleanliness, maintenance, and health and safety requirements in the lease. Screening criteria should focus on legitimate, nondiscriminatory rental qualifications rather than attempting to identify whether an applicant has a disability or hoarding disorder. Regular inspections conducted in accordance with the lease and applicable law can also help landlords identify property condition concerns before they become more serious.

FAQs About Tenant Hoarding

If you’re dealing with a tenant who may be hoarding, you probably have questions about your legal responsibilities and the best way to handle the situation. Below are answers to some of the most common questions landlords ask about tenant hoarding.

Is hoarding considered a disability?

Hoarding disorder may qualify as a disability under the Fair Housing Act. Because of this, landlords should avoid discrimination and follow all applicable fair housing requirements when addressing hoarding-related concerns.

Can a landlord evict a tenant for hoarding?

Possibly. A tenant generally should not be evicted simply because they have hoarding disorder or another disability. However, if actual conditions in the rental create serious health, safety, property damage, or lease-compliance issues that remain unresolved, eviction may ultimately be an option.

How can landlords identify signs of hoarding?

Common warning signs include excessive clutter, strong odors, pest infestations, blocked exits, unresolved maintenance issues, and complaints from neighboring tenants.

How can landlords help tenants with hoarding disorder?

Landlords should communicate respectfully, document concerns, encourage the tenant to seek professional support, and work toward resolving health and safety issues whenever possible.

Can tenant screening identify hoarding behavior?

Not always. Because hoarding disorder often develops over time and may not be obvious during the application process, regular inspections and clear lease expectations are important.

How to Protect Your Properties

Property manager helping rental property owners protect their investment through professional management servicesFinding out your tenant is a hoarder can be overwhelming for landlords. After all, you may associate hoarding with messy homes, property damage, and pest issues. However, it’s important to remember that it’s also a mental health condition that some people suffer greatly from. 

That said, it’s important to know how to handle these situations as they come up. If you suspect your tenant is hoarding, know what you can do to protect your property and prevent potential issues. 

[button text=”Need More Advice? contact us today!” style=”outline” size=”small” radius=”99″ depth=”3″ depth_hover=”5″ icon=”icon-envelop” icon_pos=”left” link=”https://www.baymgmtgroup.com/contact/” target=”_blank”]

One way to protect your properties is by hiring a comprehensive property management team. An experienced group like BMG takes tenant screening seriously, inspects properties when necessary, and performs maintenance tasks as soon as possible. If you’re looking for someone to manage your properties, contact Bay Property Management Group today!

Share this post

Related Articles